Swedes: “We do not use the word race.”
Who can claim to be Swedish? And when this claim is made, is it accepted by others? New research shows that despite the Swedish aversion to the concept of race, there is a clear image of Swedishness: white, blonde, and blue-eyed is still the standard definition.
In a new dissertation, doctoral student Caroline Adolfsson has examined perceptions of Swedishness using two constructed groups of people. One group of ethnic Swedes, that is, people with family ties, ancestry within Sweden, and who are usually white. And a second group that does not have such connections with the country. When she compares the answers, the word race evokes very negative feelings, especially in the white, ethnic Swede group.
In EU countries, as in Sweden, “ethnicity” is often preferred to “race”, although race is sometimes used within academia. In other Western countries, such as the United States, the United Kingdom and Australia, racial-ethnic identity is sometimes used as a hybrid term which can refer to a spectrum of identities relating to both terms, but the word ‘race’ is also often used on its own, explains Adolfsson.
“Many countries in Europe react to the word because of the Holocaust, as group identities were used to justify genocide. But in Sweden, the aversion evokes a very negative emotional response, and that feeling is more common among those who are part of the ethnic group. They are almost hostile to the word,” says Adolfsson, a PhD student at the Department of Global Political Studies.
“It is noteworthy that while the group of predominantly white respondents describes the division into races as something very negative, they define Swedishness with a white person. Despite the reluctance, they thus define themselves “racially”, says Adolfsson.
She emphasises the empirical evidence that people make this connection between Swedishness and whiteness.
“The fact that it can be difficult to talk about these things may be due, among other things, to a dislike of the perception of the biological link in the concept of race. The fact that Sweden had the National Institute for Racial Biology ( which had a stated purpose of studying eugenics and human genetics) may be one reason why the word has such a negative connotation here, Adolfsson believes.
Although race can be seen as a social construct, according to Adolfsson, it can still have consequences for people, as it is linked to political, historical, and social meanings.
Therefore, people still identify themselves and others as part of racial groups, and this can have different meanings for different people in different places. Even if some people want to be colour blind, we are not,” she says.
Sweden is becoming one of the most diverse countries in the Western world. At the same time, there is a perception that Swedes look a certain way.
The thesis consists of three sub-studies with attitude surveys and interviews. In the second and third sub-studies, the participants are upper secondary school students. “It is believed that young people are the most liberal and least conservative and yet we got these results – I find that interesting,” says Adolfsson.
'We don't use the word race': Boundaries of in-group membership in Sweden
The thesis consists of three parts:
1. investigated the sense of belonging to Sweden among second-generation immigrants with parents from Somalia, Vietnam, Turkey and Poland. The results show that one can feel both connected to one's background and very much like Swedes. Those with Polish roots felt more that they were regarded as Swedes than the others. 626 respondents.
2. Questions about feelings towards the word race. One group of white, ethnic Swedes, one group with immigrant background. Most agree across the groups that the Swede is usually a white person. But the white respondents are very negative, almost hostile to using the word. Forty interviews.
3. in this part, pictures of people of different ethnic backgrounds were shown to a group of ethnic Swedes and to a group of Swedes of immigrant background. Respondents were asked to rank who in the pictures looked most Swedish and most Swedish. The answer was white people. 278 participants.
